Ralph K. Bowers, Mount Union 1917-1929

Richard J. Young, Miami 1929-1961

Jack L. Anson, Colgate 1961-1970

William D. Jenkins, Bowling Green 1970-1978

John W. Meyerhoff, Colgate 1978-1987

John M. Green, Nebraska Wesleyan 1987-1998

Joel Rudy, Bethany 1998-2002

C. Steven Hartman, Muskingum 2002-present